GeM Project Proposal - Review Form

Reviewer Name*

Project Title (PIs)*

Analysis of miRNA (miRNome) and miRNA biogenesis genes mutations in MPNST (Kozlowski)

Other

Hypothesis - Please consider the following:*

• Can the proposed hypothesis be addressed with the GeM data set? • Has the investigator requested the appropriate "level" of data to address the hypothesis?

Overall Merit and Feasibility - Please consider the following:*

• Significance of proposed hypothesis in field of NF1/MPNST research • Approach (good rationale, appropriate methodology, etc.) • Are sufficient details provided?

Authorship Plan - Please consider the following:*

• Does the authorship plan proposed by the investigators align with GeM policy? • Is the authorship plan appropriate for the "level" of data requested? • Does the PI indicate interest in collaboration with other GeM members?

Does the proposed research overlap with any other project proposals using GeM data?*

Note: we want to avoid redundancies in research efforts and encourage collaboration between GeM members who may have proposed similar research projects

Feedback to Investigator(s)*

Please provide feedback to the investigator(s) or ask any clarifying questions here:

Determination*

Based on your best judgment and the feedback you have provided, do you believe this project proposal should be approved?

Yes

Provisional - with changes (please describe below)

Notes to review committee, working group, etc.

Please provide any additional feedback here that may help other GeM Consortium members understand your determination

Send me a copy of my responses

Privacy Notice|Report Abuse