GeM Project Proposal - Review Form

Reviewer Name

Project Title (PIs)

Analysis of miRNA (miRNome) and miRNA biogenesis genes mutations in MPNST (Kozlowski)

Other

Hypothesis - Please consider the following:

• Can the proposed hypothesis be addressed with the GeM data set? • Has the investigator requested the appropriate "level" of data to address the hypothesis?

Overall Merit and Feasibility - Please consider the following:

• Significance of proposed hypothesis in field of NF1/MPNST research • Approach (good rationale, appropriate methodology, etc.) • Are sufficient details provided?

Authorship Plan - Please consider the following:

• Does the authorship plan proposed by the investigators align with GeM policy? • Is the authorship plan appropriate for the "level" of data requested? • Does the PI indicate interest in collaboration with other GeM members?

Does the proposed research overlap with any other project proposals using GeM data?

Note: we want to avoid redundancies in research efforts and encourage collaboration between GeM members who may have proposed similar research projects

Feedback to Investigator(s)

Please provide feedback to the investigator(s) or ask any clarifying questions here:

Determination

Based on your best judgment and the feedback you have provided, do you believe this project proposal should be approved?

Yes

Provisional - with changes (please describe below)

Notes to review committee, working group, etc.

Please provide any additional feedback here that may help other GeM Consortium members understand your determination

Send me a copy of my responses

Report Abuse